Welcome...

Welcome to the Leadership21 blog, an ongoing conversation on mental health, civil rights and social justice. Posting on the blog are twelve young mental health advocates who comprise the L21 commitee, and anything goes--the personal, the political, the cultural, whatever! We hope that you'll check out what's here, and make some comments, and please know that if you're concerned about anonymity, you can comment anonymously. We hope that what you read, and what you contribute, will make you want to return regularly, because to our knowledge, there really isn't anything out there that has the potential to engage people on so many levels about mental health. But we need "outsiders" like you to make it grow into a robust, contagious online blog. So thanks for coming, welcome to the conversation, and please, pass it on--L21

Friday, August 31, 2007

disability -- casting too broad a net?

Posted by Lucy

Yesterday I met with a deaf woman who told me that she didn’t go to a therapist for her PTSD symptoms because she’s not “one of those crazy people” – signed by waving the hands around the head with a disgusted face – and I refrained from scolding her for having such scorn for people who experience mental illness.

A little over a week ago a person in the mental hospital informed me in a very loud voice that they were not “a retard” and wanted a new roommate that [didn’t have a developmental disability.]


An hour ago a would-be law clerk contacted me about writing a paper about state law requirements to report abuse of persons with disability that trump the privileges of lawyers, clergy, and social workers, requiring them to call in to the state any abuse of a “person with a disability.” This law would require me to report it to the government were a deaf client to tell me in confidence that her boyfriend had hit her!

Why is it that many people with disabilities are constantly trying to distance themselves from being lumped together with other disability groups? I always assumed it was the pressures people with disability confront in society that cause them to push harder on others perceived to be “beneath” them. But could it be the law itself – our own legal category of “disability” – that causes my clients to distance themselves from one another time and again?

Is the law the REASON these groups are at pains to distinguish themselves from each other?

1 comment:

Lizzie Simon said...

I don't consider my self disabled--and yet having bipolar disorder has certainly been a disability at different points of my life---this is a touchy subject for a lot of us.