Welcome...

Welcome to the Leadership21 blog, an ongoing conversation on mental health, civil rights and social justice. Posting on the blog are twelve young mental health advocates who comprise the L21 commitee, and anything goes--the personal, the political, the cultural, whatever! We hope that you'll check out what's here, and make some comments, and please know that if you're concerned about anonymity, you can comment anonymously. We hope that what you read, and what you contribute, will make you want to return regularly, because to our knowledge, there really isn't anything out there that has the potential to engage people on so many levels about mental health. But we need "outsiders" like you to make it grow into a robust, contagious online blog. So thanks for coming, welcome to the conversation, and please, pass it on--L21

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

On Memoir

An editor at a major publishing house recently sent me a memoir about bipolar disorder. She wanted me to consider writing a blurb for it, and I said sure. So I read the memoir--and basically it's the story of a totally out of control woman who has bp--it goes through many of her dysfunctional relationships, and also her attempts at recovery, and it does almost everything I hate that writing about bp can do, in its narcissism, its glorification of illness, its use of illness to excuse flaws, its utter lack of insight for others, etc, etc, etc. This is a book that lets you gawk at a crazy person, but doesn't transcend that very limited, and arguably useless experience. Needless to day I declined the opportunity to blurb it. But this has been a creative preoccupation of mine for years, and now, as I am about to start teaching writing this summer, I am wanting to clarify: how do you make writing about mental illnes artful, relevant, useful? Does any body want to cite books they felt did or did not achieve that goal?

2 comments:

Allison White said...

I've often wondered the same thing. Oftentimes, in portrayals of individuals with eating disorders, they will glamorize and glorify the illness. People have asked me, "How can a[film/book/show] possibly glamorize an eating disorder?" and I have difficulty answering their question. I'm honestly not sure how someone could share their experiences without glamorizing the illness. I suppose if you were to stick to the emotions, facts, possible causes/effects, and successful methods of treatment rather than focusing on the extremes (i.e. lowest weight, disordered eating, behaviors) then it can transcend storytelling and become more of a lesson...Any thoughts?

KleoPatra said...

i thought your own book hit the mark, Lizzie. Though what Allison White, above, wrote here, rings true with most writings about surviving (or even dealing with) an illness (emotional or physical) coming across as glamorizing either the illness itself or the person who has been identified as the one with the illness...